ST. LOUIS, Mo. (KMOV) – The mother and father of a St. Louis teenager who was gunned down for witnessing one other homicide is suing town, claiming their son’s dying was preventable, and the plan to kill him was hatched inside town jail on recorded cellphone calls.
4 individuals had been arrested and charged with the teenager’s homicide, but none had been convicted.
Information 4 Investigates uncovers jail name recordings and information town gained’t share publicly, because the household questions if justice was really served.
MURDER AT THE BUS STOP
On the morning of Sept. 5, 2017, James Scales Jr. stood exterior his household’s North Metropolis house, ready for the varsity bus.
St. Louis Police stated the teenager was shot a number of instances. James ran inside his home, the place his mother referred to as 911.
“My son been shot up actual dangerous,” James’ mother might be heard saying on the 911 name recording. “He’s not doing something. It’s a variety of blood. My complete hallway is crammed up with blood.”
There was nothing anybody might do; James was pronounced lifeless on the hospital.
“My baby is gone now when you might have prevented it,” stated James’ mother.
James’ household agreed to speak to Information 4 Investigates however requested that their names not be used since they’re involved for his or her security.
When James was killed, he was the principle witness in a homicide case. James’ household says he by no means obtained witness safety Missouri regulation and St. Louis metropolis coverage promise.
James’ household say the person he was alleged to testify towards, 19-year-old Keith Graham deliberate James’ homicide whereas he was within the Metropolis Justice Middle and on recorded jailhouse calls.
“They killed him so he wouldn’t maintain going to court docket telling what he knew, what he noticed,” James’ mother stated.
For her, that’s certainly one of a number of failures. She, together with James’ dad and stepparents, are taking town to court docket, suing for wrongful dying and negligence.
“They had been supposed to maintain him secure, that’s what they stated, to not lose one other life,” James’ mother stated.
2016 MURDER CASE
In 2016, the day after Christmas, James and his buddy, 18-year-old Dwayne Clanton, had been strolling house from a buddy’s home when Clanton was shot and killed. James’ household says James reported what and who he noticed to the police, considering his identify could be confidential.
“They are saying nameless tip, no that’s a lie, it’s nearly like fraud,” James’ mother stated.
Police arrested Graham, and he was charged with Clanton’s homicide.
James’ mother claims somebody put James’ identify and deal with on court docket information. Information 4 investigates tried to get a replica, however the information are sealed as a result of Graham was acquitted.
“You gave them the deal with like, ‘hey right here’s the place yow will discover him, that’s who advised on you,’” James’ mother stated.
Town gained’t discuss to Information 4 Investigates about that. In court docket information, prosecutors stated Graham discovered about James as a result of “phrase reached” him.
Prosecutors say over the course of months, Graham, who was in jail, referred to as pals on the surface, planning to “seek out and kill” James.
These pals are William Pearson Jr., Terez Prepare dinner, and Devion Gordon. All three had been arrested and charged with James’ homicide.
JAIL CALL RECORDINGS EXPOSE MURDER PLOT
Jail name recordings had been a essential focus of the investigation. Information 4 Investigates requested copies of the recordings from prosecutors. Prosecutors haven’t launched any information to Information 4 and haven’t supplied any reasoning for why they’re withholding the information. As a substitute, Information 4 Investigates obtained the jail name recordings from a decide.
One of many first jail calls got here days after Graham’s arrest. In court docket information, prosecutors say he requested Gordon for assist getting out.
“In the event you rush, they’re going to seem like oh he orchestrated one thing to return up out of there, almost certainly your cellphone name is being recorded bro,” prosecutors declare Gordon stated.
Later within the name, Graham might be heard within the recording saying, “so all they want is a witness and I’m f*****, huh? I’m lifeless, huh?”
“Yeah,” prosecutors declare Gordon responds.
“I’m lifeless then,” Graham stated.
On one other day, prosecutors say Graham had a three-way name with Gordon and Pearson the place they talked about getting him out in two months.
Virtually two months after that cellphone name, somebody shot up James’ home. Nobody was damage, and James wasn’t house on the time.
Within the responding officer’s report, he famous it was a “attainable retaliation” as a result of James was a witness in a “murder investigation.”
James’ household declare they requested for defense that day.
“It wasn’t a lot they may do. They didn’t give us no assist. We simply left the house,” James’ mother defined.
Two days after the capturing, prosecutors declare Pearson might be heard on a recorded name telling Graham the hit on James’ home didn’t work.
“I’m out of the jam?” Graham might be heard asking on the recording.
“Oh that m*********** ain’t nowhere. Nowhere, I imply nowhere,” prosecutors declare Pearson stated.
Over the subsequent few months, James’ household says James was threatened a number of instances. Of their lawsuit, the household claims James was shot at whereas strolling alongside Kingshighway Boulevard. In response to the go well with, on one other day a person confirmed up at their home and advised them “to not go to court docket.” Within the lawsuit, the household says they repeatedly requested police and protecting companies for assist.
“We reached out like, ‘hey can ya’ll place us someplace, can y’all do one thing?’ Nothing was achieved,” James’ mother stated.
Prosecutors say jail name recordings present Graham continued to name his pals to make plans to kill James.
“We going to do my plan. So, it – you good bro I say that. I obtained you,” prosecutors declare Gordon advised Graham in a single name recording. “You going to see it simply maintain watching the information.”
Inside a couple of months, James’ household and prosecutors imagine the plan went by way of when James was shot and killed.
Jail name logs present the day James died Graham talked to Gordon, who police imagine made it clear he didn’t wish to discuss concerning the capturing however acknowledged the plan went by way of.
“Earlier than you say something bro don’t name my cellphone speaking about none of that,” prosecutors declare Gordon stated.
Earlier than hanging up, prosecutors declare Gordon advised Graham, “simply come on house man.”
On high of dozens of recorded jail calls, proof included cellphone GPS knowledge which police declare put Pearson and Prepare dinner within the “fast space” when James was killed. Court docket information present investigators discovered a ballistics match, which means a gun used to shoot up James’ home was additionally utilized in his homicide.
Virtually six months after James was killed, Keith Graham, William Pearson Jr., Terez Prepare dinner and Devion Gordon had been all charged within the homicide.
2022 MURDER TRIAL
The trial began in April 2022. It took greater than 4 years to get to that time. In that point the Scales household declare prosecutors mishandled proof. Prosecutors inform Information 4 Investigates they will’t remark due to the lawsuit.
Days earlier than the trial started, the decide advised prosecutors they couldn’t use dozens of jail calls. In a court docket order, the decide claimed prosecutors broke a regular rule of our judicial system and by no means turned over the entire calls to protection attorneys.
The decide additionally let protection attorneys inform the jury there could also be proof that would have helped their shopper’s case.
Ultimately, the jury didn’t discover anybody responsible of homicide. They acquitted Pearson, Prepare dinner and Gordon. Graham was acquitted for the homicide James witnessed and James’ dying. Nevertheless, the jury did discover Graham was concerned in James’ dying. He was convicted of conspiracy to commit homicide and tampering with a witness, each felonies.
Graham is in jail serving a 10-year sentence. Information 4 Investigates reached out to all 4 males and their attorneys; none went on the report.
On the time of the arrests in James’ homicide, St. Louis Circuit Legal professional Kim Gardner launched the next assertion:
“Witness and sufferer security is certainly one of my high priorities, as witness intimidation strikes on the coronary heart of the justice system. Once I took workplace, I said that we had been going to do extra prosecutor-lead investigations in an effort to assist scale back violent crime and construct confidence within the legal justice system.
The case we charged as we speak is a wonderful instance of how priceless most of these investigations might be to public security. My staff of prosecutors have been working for months on this case with the help of the police division, and we imagine we’ve got the proof we have to maintain these 4 people accountable for his or her actions.”
Gardner wouldn’t remark for this story.
“There was no justice in any respect,” James’ mother stated.
James’ household sued town earlier than the trial and the acquittals, which is why the lawsuit focuses on the household’s declare that James wasn’t given witness safety.
“It actually was only a failure at each single degree, at each single flip,” stated one of many household’s attorneys, Andrea McNairy, a Accomplice with Brown & Crouppen.
The household’s attorneys argue police and prosecutors had months to assist James however didn’t.
“Town has an entire bunch of insurance policies, procedures, guidelines that they’ve in writing, these don’t do a variety of good in the event that they’re ignored,” stated the household’s lawyer Anthony Laramore, a Senior Trial Lawyer on the Mutrux Agency.
POLICY ON PROTECTING WITNESSES
In St. Louis the “Witness/Sufferer Safety unit” is run by the prosecutor’s workplace, and police are alleged to work with them to guard witnesses.
The process for what’s alleged to occur is specified by a Particular Order that the police division doesn’t need the general public to find out about. Information 4 Investigates requested for a replica of the coverage in an open information request. The police division launched a replica with massive sections of redactions, claiming these components usually are not open to the general public.
Information 4 obtained an unredacted copy that police gave attorneys.
One of many sections police hid explains, “any menace to a sufferer or witness will probably be documented.” The coverage additionally states if there’s a right away menace officers need to take “no matter safety measures obligatory” and so they have to assist make a “persevering with plan” to guard the witness.
“Individuals are attempting to cover the ball and our shoppers are nonetheless struggling due to it,” Laramore added.
Regardless of continued calls and emails, nobody on the St. Louis Metro Police Division, or the Prosecutor’s Workplace will discuss to Information 4 Investigates concerning the case and cited the pending lawsuit as why.
Police did ship Information 4 an e-mail saying they comply with their coverage on witness safety. The e-mail said that James died earlier than the police division had its personal “sufferer advocate unit” which permits them “to do extra.”
MILLIONS SET ASIDE TO PROTECT WITNESSES
Throughout the state police have been given extra money to guard witnesses.
Final 12 months lawmakers created the “Pretrial Witness Safety Providers Fund.” It put aside $2 million that police can apply for by sending statements for prices associated to witness safety.
Information 4 Investigates uncovered a lot of the cash is untouched. At this level, lower than $20,000 has been spent.
State information present solely 4 departments obtained funds, that features St. Louis police who requested round $7,000.
“The issue is I don’t suppose that program is the answer,” stated Missouri State Rep. Peter Merideth (D-St. Louis).
Merideth helps approve the funds. When requested if he believes one thing must be achieved concerning the fund Merideth responded, “Sure. I will probably be reaching out for one to town to see if there’s something I can do on my finish on the state degree to deal with that, or in the event that they want a distinct program fully which frankly, I feel is the reply.”
Merideth says he needs to unravel why the cash isn’t being spent, however he believes one motive is that folks don’t all the time belief the police.
“In the event that they already don’t belief regulation enforcement, they don’t belief that they’re truly going to be secure in that state of affairs,” Merideth added.
Any belief is gone with James’ household, who now hopes their lawsuit sends a message.
“It was only a job for you, it was a caseload, however you failed us,” James’ mother stated. “I do know one factor for certain, they didn’t defend James.”
Copyright 2022 KMOV. All rights reserved.