Pepe’s Pizza – Plains – NEPA Pizza Evaluate

Pepe’s Pizza in Plains is a superb little hidden gem within the Wilkes-Barre space. Many individuals “within the know” have beneficial I do that pizzeria through the years. Fortunately, I discovered myself within the space and known as in an order for a medium pizza with candy sauce. I’m usually a daily sauce man, however the suggestions was overwhelmingly in favor of the candy sauce – so I went with what the individuals beneficial.

When driving as much as Pepe’s Pizza, I undoubtedly felt a familiarity with the world, and as soon as I noticed Plains Pub throughout the road I knew why! Pepe’s is an old-fashioned pizzeria the place you’ll be able to see proper into the kitchen. It’s as right down to earth as you may get.

Blast From the Previous!

Joke, I finished in for the primary time and the proprietor was extraordinarily welcoming to me and we obtained to speaking. As we talked, I undoubtedly knew that we had met earlier than – after which it hit me! We had labored collectively at a pizzeria for a short while a pair many years in the past! We shared some reminiscences, I snapped a number of images of the pizza and I excused myself to go overview the pizza in personal (aka on the hood of my automotive)!

Pepe’s Pizza Plains beautifully cooked bottom crust.
A take a look at the fantastically baked backside crust of Pepe’s Pizza in Plains.

The pizza appeared excellent. It was a skinny crust New York type pizza cooked good and crispy, barely on the nicely achieved aspect identical to I prefer it! The cheese was melted fantastically and caramelized in some spots. It had a richness and slight saltiness to it that contrasted the sweeter sauce magnificently. The sauce had a stunning physique and clean texture to it. The sweetness was offered in a singular means that wasn’t overpowering or sugary, and had a satisfying mellow tang to it.

Total, I used to be very impressed with the pizza. It’s a no frills throwback pizzeria stuffed with character and character. Individuals advised me it was a welcoming place and the proprietor made me really feel like a daily the second I stepped within the door. Extremely advocate!

Pepe’s Pizza Score Scores

Pepe’s Pizza Plains New York Style Pizza with Sweet Sauce
Pepe’s Pizza Plains New York Model Pizza with Candy Sauce
  • Restaurant: Pepe’s Pizza & Subs
  • Location: 52 E Carey St, Wilkes-Barre, PA 18705
  • Date: April 2023
  • Pizza Ordered: Medium New York Model with Candy Sauce
Score Class Score Rating
Crust 8.5
Sauce 8.3
Cheese 8.3
Style 8.6
Crispy/Cooked Correctly 9.1
Worth 7.6
Total Score 8.5
Score of Pepe’s Pizza in Plains Candy Sauce Pizza

The Pizza is Much like: Shelley’s Pizza, Dino and Francesco’s, Grande Pizza

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *